your 4 banger has less HP, BUT it has more low-end torque.
The 2.5l doesn't have any low-end torque. A 90s model 2.5 made max torque at 3,500rpm(sully's 4.2 makes max torque at 1,800rpm) and max HP at a little over 5,000. That's why they had the 4.11:1 diff ratios, they take less torque to turn over and they allow the engine to get up into the higher rpms faster where it makes power.
For example: A car like a 69 Camaro with a TH350 auto, and a 327cid smallblock and a 290 degree cam would run best with around a 3.90-4.11 rear gear. That same car with a 427cid bigblock and a 290 duration cam would run best with a 3.23-3.55 ratio. The same thing is true for the six versus the four in Jeeps. The six runs best with a slightly "tall" diff gear, while the four needs lower gears to let it get up in rpms where it likes to run.
launch that 2.5l at about 3,000 rpm and don't shift until 5,500rpm+. A hopped up 2.5l can drop some jaws when driven like it needs to be driven. :wink:
=========
thanks for the info on the FI redrooster, I'll give those guys a call when I'm ready.....hopefully by next winter.