Sparky-Watts said:
Junkpile said:
SWB gets my vote
Practical? By what standards? For what purpose?
An XJ is in no way the most practical choice for me.
Gotta go with Junkpile on this one....no way would I ever own an XJ. Big, cumbersome, heavy, long grocery-getters. If I wanted a vehicle to haul stuff in, I'd get a pickup...oh, I have one of those. If I wanted a vehicle to haul passengers in, I'd get a car...oh, I have one of those, too. If I wanted a vehicle to tackle the obstacles off-road, then I'd get a Wrangler...oh, I have one of those, too!!! SWB is the ONLY way to wheel!!
Obviously you guys disagree with me because you guys don't know what the hell you're talking about. :twisted: JK.
I figured it goes without saying that it's practicality is relative to the activities one enjoys.
It's a matter of opinion, and that's what the Orig. poster requested. I gave mine and the reasons why. I own both types of jeeps, and IMO XJ is more practical. Better? No. I love them both.
For ex: a volvo station wagon is more practical than a Harley. Better? maybe not.
Sparky, if you wanted to haul passengers, haul stuff and 4 wheel drive, yeah sure, it would be better to get all 3 of those vehicles. BUT, why not save your cash and get an XJ. I can't afford 3 vehicles personally.
An XJ isn't the best tow vehicle.
It's not the best passenger vehicle.
It's not the best vehicle for hauling stuff.
Best trail rig? Debatably not.
Best hill- climber? Maybe not.
Camping rig? Well perhaps an RV is better.
But it's pretty darn good at all the above, and that's pretty darn practical by my standards.
Next time you need to go pickup a computer desk at Best Buy, take your wranger and tell me if it's practicle. Take your YJ camping, and tell me if you can take more gear than I without the help of a trailer or ten types of racks and doo dads.
I'm not saying the XJ is better. I love my TJ and it does many things my XJ can't (and visa versa). But it sure ain't the most sensible and practial vehicle for the populace at large.
Tell me in what ways a SWB Jeep is more "practical" for you all. Perhaps it's just a nomenclature difference in terms of the definition of the word.
I shop for furniture
Camp
Hunt
fish
Get groceries :lol:
Travel
Make liquor runs
Trail ride
For me, I needed a vehicle that can "Cross Train."