Things that will affect mileage (for the worse)
A soft top will eat 2 or 3 mpg compared to a hard top (wind resistance)
A lift will hurt mileage, mostly do due to increased drag under the vehicle. Almost always a lift will include larger tires and wheels - more rolling resistance and more weight (200 to 300 pounds more weight in the wheels and often another 100 pounds in the lift kit over stock)
My 90 YJ with a 3" lift, 32" mudders, 305 4Bbl chevy 4 speed auto and 4:10 gears averages about 11 mpg If I baby it and run naked it does a bit better, but highway speeds with the top on it can get me down into the single digits.
I'm planning a long trip next year and am starting to look for some near-stock wheels/tires in the hope I can get 15 on the hiway when I'm done.