Bestop, hands down. I've had mine now 7 years and it looks the same the day I put it on, no fading in the desert heat, all the huge Zytel zippers and fasteners work perfectly, all the window combinations come off and on with ease, stays taught in hot or cold, rail fold to body is extremely clever, yet comes off so easy it literally undoes itself once you slide the keepers to 'slack mode'.
After nearly 50 years of Jeeps, this is the best soft top. Funny too, 39 years ago I had a Bestop when they were first in business and in the Jeep world, it was the worst top ever made along with Kayline, Sears, J. C Whitney. Then, the top top of all time was the awesome Whitco soft top for the 5-- so rocked. But nothing like the modern Bestop of today....
Robert