You would really have to upload a picture of your jeep for us to give you a solid opinion.
What year wrangler?
What is the function or look that you are trying to achieve?
if you put either of those on a stock wrangler with no lift or other bells a whistles, I'm afraid it would look pretty silly.
I didn't have to make a choice... my wrangler had aftermarket bumpers on it when I bought it.
I kind of like the Body Armor look for my '91 YJ