I can view this in one way, from two sides.... No, I don't think it has much, or any, value to the board... it simply shows how many times a person has written something, and hit the submit button... BUT... then... having it there, it hurts nothing at all... I appreciate the time that Terry puts into it to do what he can to keep this board's roots tied in with the old roots...
then, there IS some validity to knowing how often people post... The moderators may want to know who is active in a board... if there is a member who joined a year and a half ago, posted once, and has never posted again... there is a chance that he/she is no longer with us... I'm not sure how the board works, but it may, or may not, affect the amount of work that our big shots have to do in order to keep this all running... I don't think that Terry would want to have to carry over hundreds of names of people that signed up a year ago, posted once, then never returned.
I also agree with some of the statements about the "star system"... it gives newbies an idea of who they can come to with questions, or it gives them an idea of how accurate someones reply to a question may be... I DON'T think that a "ranking system" should have to do with a post count, but if there were to be a ranking system, it should be based on board activity, not senseless activity, but based on how much the person sees, and the validity of their posts..
But then... if a newbie comes along, and wants to know where to get answers, if he/she sticks around and watches the board for 2 days... he/she will easily understand that everyone here is willing to give every bit of helpful advice that they possibly can.. Some know more than others, but then... I know more than many people... but then... I can guarantee that every person that doesn't know AS MUCH as me, knows many things that I DON'T know
So... if the post count stays, it doesn't bother me... if it falls off the earth, oh well... If we get a ranking system, maybe it will benefit someone, maybe not... but again, if there is no "ranking system"... i'm not bothered
I think that anyone around here, whether for 2 years, or 2 days, will be able to tell where the members stand... which to me, is all at the same place... we all come here to learn, we all come here to share... all willing to ask, all willing to help