I had a TJ...but I offroad for work, and I have to carry too much equipment into the boonies, so, the TJ was just too small, despite being able to GET to places, it had to make two trips to CARRY everything...which is impossible when the location is more than a couple of hours away, etc.
So I got an Xterra, which was perfect really, except the front axle was broken into two parts, right from the factory, which sucked, but, I was able to modify it to work well anyway....but I missed JEEPING out into the boonies.
When the 4 Dr JK came out, I was also grossed out, I mean, that's how most classics die...they get bigger every year, until they are to far gone from what they are supposed to be...
But, over time, it grew on me...and, the wife needed a new truck, so I hedged my bet, as SHE liked it, and got the 4 dr JK.
It grew on me more, we both off roaded it, Pine Barrens, Rausch Creek, etc...and it WORKS. It just works off road...I was surprised how well the ******* did...and, now, I'm a fan of them.
I think of it as sort of a Cherokee with a frame.